Mutual Fund Site

A mutual fund’s expense ratios essentially tell an investor how much money the fund spends in terms of, well, expenses. And when all of us in the rest of the world are so concerned about expenses, how we spend our money, should we not be concerned about the way people who come up with our investment strategy spend theirs? Or does the expense ratio even matter, especially if the mutual fund itself provides spectacular returns?

There are plenty of arguments that suggest one over the other. And it makes sense that expenses, regardless of the business (whether you invest in mutual funds, equities, or even your own business), be kept under control. But in reality, a fund’s returns are measured post-expenses. Take the following as an example:

Fund A has an expense ratio of 1.25% yet its 3-year annualized rate of return is 12.5%. Fund B has an expense ratio of 0.55%, yet its 5-year annualized rate of return is just 8%. Is Fund A worth the premium, or is Fund B the better fund?

Measured strictly on rates of return (RoR), Fund A is the better performer. However, there could be many different considerations that need to come into question before deciding whether one should invest in Fund A or Fund B. Assuming each fund is in the same category and sub-category, one would have to consider the number of securities under management and the fund’s turnover ratio (the higher these numbers, the higher the expense should be), the level of risk (maybe a better performing fund is not what an investor wants if it means considerably more risk) and the tenure of management (a longer, more tenured management team suggests positive returns are more sustainable than a fund that has just recently returned good rates under a new management team).

Yes, these other considerations are the very reason for why sites like the Mutual Fund Site (a watered-down conversational site) and Morningstar (a straight, by-the-numbers site), etc., exist.

In our opinion, expense ratios do not matter when rates of return alone are an investor’s main concern. However, expense ratios do matter when one investigates why it is seemingly higher or lower than its competitors’. Because above the expenses, an investor needs to make sure that any mutual fund, regardless of expenses, aligns with his or her overall investment strategy.

To find get started, find out what your Asset Allocation Model is, right here at MutualFundSite.org.